Tooth Cookie Cutter With Custom Handle By West Tinworks

Sold by Tinworks
+ $3.50 shipping
+ $3.50 shipping
In stock
Ships next business day
Arrives from the United States

Made in Fort Mill, South Carolina

Item details


Molar tooth cookie cutter outline is 4" H. x 2 1/2" W. with 5/8" cutter depth, and fabricated of 0.010" USA tin-plated steel. Assembled with lead-free solder. Ready to ship same or next day after purchase! Usually arrives within two to three days in the USA....Ships first class mail from South Carolina; upgrades are available at checkout.

Each of my cookie cutters is uniquely designed and made completely by hand in my Fort Mill, SC shop. My cutters start out as a flat sheet of metal; strips are cut, edges are folded and the cutter is hand formed and soldered one by one. Finally a custom handle is soldered on the cutter, and the completed cutter is cleaned and inspected. My maker's mark "W" is hand stamped with pride on each handle. A special forming tool is used to assure close conformance with the images show.

Tinworks exclusive COOKIE CUTTERS can only be purchased from us - West Tinworks! Designed and handcrafted in the USA by Larry and Diana West. Larry West Master Tinsmith has over 30 years of experience making unique high quality collectible cookie cutters.

A cutter you can use to make cookies for your favorite dentist or dental hygienist. When the tooth fairy comes, cookies, brownies and sandwiches would be a fun special treat. We also include our delicious Butter Cookie Cutter Recipe for your enjoyment!

The Tin Molar Tooth Cutter is not just the average cutter you will find everywhere else. We incorporate a custom handle in our design which makes the cutter, stronger, more stable and easier to use. The tin plated steel material we use gives a nice clean precise cut every time. This cutter is an Exclusive Original Design and can only be purchased from West Tinworks.

Ideal for making party treats. Also use our handmade cutter for fondant, noodles, cheese, meat, pie dough, hors d’oeuvres, crackers, veggies, gelatin, fun dough, mints, ornaments, clay or to trim packages.

Our special complementary Butter Cookie Cutter Recipe included!

This cutter is ready to ship, and all domestic shipments include confirmation/tracking!

    Average review
    I was looking for a unique thank you gift for my Bible study leader, who is office manager at a dental practice-she loved it and said she'd be using it to make sugar cookies for the dentist 💙
    Nov 28, 2017 by HeidiCompton
    These are gifts for myself and my friends . We are all in the dental field and love sweets, so what better than a tooth shaped cookie cutter to make those sweets? Love them. Arrived fast and they had a card for each on I purchased that had a cookie recipe on it. NICE!!
    Sep 12, 2017 by Grin Gal
    May 16, 2016 by Emily Pressley
    Good quality product. Shipped very fast.
    Mar 15, 2016 by Fern
    Cookie cutter is beautifully made, and arrived very quickly.
    Dec 15, 2015 by Becky Chatham

Shipping & policies
Ships next business day
Arrives from the United States
Estimated Shipping
Shipping to
Zip or postal code

Items are shipped same or next business day, including Saturdays, depending on time of day the order is received. All items listed in our shop are in-stock and ready to ship. Our standard shipping carrier is USPS, and standard service is first class (up to 13 ounces) or Priority Mail (over 13 ounces); both provide delivery confirmation/tracking, and Priority Mail includes insurance. See for delivery time estimates from zip 29640. Available shipping upgrades not offered to (or not selected by) customers during checkout are handled through PayPal invoice or a shipping upgrade listing (paid prior to shipment) and only in response to customer request.

LARGE ORDERS: Please send a message to request best shipping price on larger orders:

WHAT IF YOUR ORDER TRACKING STATUS IS "DELIVERED": Time is of the essence for finding a misplaced package. The faster you act, the more likely your package will be found. When the item is delivered at your address, the carrier will scan the package and enter it as delivered. If your package status is DELIVERED, but you have not received it, please check with all household members and in locations near your address. Carriers may leave a package on a porch, tucked inside a door, etc. If you still cannot locate your package, please contact your local Post Office.

INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING: If your country, or "Everywhere Else", does not appear in the item listing, please send a conversation requesting rates. Tinworks customers are responsible for payment of any and all applicable taxes, tariffs, and import duty. Customers outside the USA are cautioned to become informed about their country's import regulations and expected Customs delay time. Tinworks is not responsible for shipping delays incurred in-transit, including import clearance procedures. All taxes, duties fees or levies charged at point of entry to the buyer’s country are the buyer’s responsibility.

TRANSIT TIME: Please realize that we have no way of knowing how long your package will take to get to you. We can estimate a US delivery date, but can make no promises. We can not estimate a delivery date for any international packages, because there are too many variables.


====Due to recent Etsy changes, SHIPPING OPTIONS are not displayed until you view your cart. Additional cutters ship at a reduced rate of $.50 in the US, and Priority Mail/Express shipping upgrades are available for many of our items.====

If you ever have a question or concern about any of my items, or service provided, please message me immediately for resolution. Payment terms are stated in the item listing page or in my special request response.

Tinworks customers are responsible for payment of any and all applicable taxes, tariffs, and import duty. South Carolina customers are required to pay SC sales tax, at Lancaster County rate, at time of checkout. Customers outside the USA are cautioned to become informed about their country's import regulations.

INTERNATIONAL BUYERS: Please do not ask us to mark your package as anything other than merchandise; to do so would be in violation of Customs Regulations.

Returns & exchanges
I gladly accept returns and exchanges
Contact me within: 14 days of delivery
Ship items back within: 30 days of delivery
I don't accept cancellations
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
The following items can't be returned or exchanged
Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:
  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Perishable products (like food or flowers)
  • Digital downloads
Conditions of return
Buyers are responsible for return shipping costs. If the item is not returned in its original condition, the buyer is responsible for any loss in value.
Additional return information
Tinworks would like for all of our customers to be happy with their purchases; if our item does not meet your expectations, please let us know immediately. Sorry, due to health reasons we can not accept returns on cookie cutters.

Returns will be accepted only for items in original condition and only with prior authorization requested through Etsy convo within 15 days after purchase. Please be advised that you will be responsible for all shipping costs. Please package the item carefully for return via USPS lowest rate available. If the return is received damaged due to inadequate packaging, we will be unable to provide a refund.

Items confirmed defective, or damaged in shipment, will be replaced or refunded only with prior authorization requested through Etsy convo within 5 business days after receipt.

We cannot replace or refund misplaced orders that are confirmed “delivered” by USPS.

If you ever have a question or concern about any of my items, or service provided, please message Tinworks immediately for resolution.

Additional policies

Newly listed items that have not previously been in my Etsy shop are added frequently, so please visit often.

Tinworks values customer feedback, and you are encouraged to provide it. Please do not leave negative (less than 5 stars) without contacting us first. I would like to be afforded the opportunity to address your concerns and resolve them to your satisfaction.

I value opportunities to create something special for my customers. If you don’t see the exact design, size or quantity you need, please request your custom item through etsy conversation; please provide as much information as possible to include what you want, when you want it and where you want it delivered. Please read my following shop policy regarding custom cookie cutters before requesting your special cutter design.

=============CUSTOM CUTTER ORDER PROCESS================
Custom orders are currently negotiated through Etsy conversation and fulfilled via a Reserved Listing. Please send your requirements, concepts, date needed, shipping location, etc. for consideration and quote. Following is our specific process for custom cutters.

We charge $20 MINIMUM for producing artwork, a MINIMUM of $45 for tooling and one simple cutter with a handle, and $3.25 MINIMUM for standard US shipping. Bottom-line delivered cost for one simple custom cutter that we design is $68.25.
To obtain the lowest quote for your cutter you must provide artwork (exact outline with dimensions). More complex cutters, with intricate bends, inside cutouts or high number of bends, as well as very small cutters, require more skill and time and will incur additional charges. Additional simple cutters, made from the same tool, are typically priced about $10.00 each. If you want exclusive use of the design, a $100 fee applies for all designs except your company logo.

Custom orders for cookie/clay/fondant cutters can usually be completed within 2 weeks. We do encourage customers to plan ahead and to have the necessary resources available. Specifically, we need an exact outline of the cutter, measurements of overall height and width, and you must have a PayPal account, or credit card for up-front payment. We use 30-gauge (.010 inch) tin-plated steel in our standard cutters for a sharp cutting edge, and we assemble cutters with lead-free solder. Copper cutters in 12-ounce (.016 inch) solid copper and heavy-duty tin plate cutters are available at additional cost.

Professional cookie makers typically are able to pay for their custom cutter with the first few orders sold, and the labor-savings continue to add up every time it is used. Clay artists may realize an even faster payback. Our stated goal is to provide a high quality product at a price that provides excellent value for our customers.

Larry & Diana West
West Tinworks